TOP 10 Best Baby Crib Mattress Reviews And Buying Guide

We are here with 10 best baby crib mattress reviews and the crib mattress buying guide to help you buy the appropriate product. For the baby crib, you need a firm and satisfactory mattress that will not disturb your baby’s sleep and keep them in a cozy environment at night. Before scrolling through the reviews you should check out the guide and know some facts.

Crib Mattress Buying Guide

You will see different types of mattresses such as breathable, foam, innerspring and organic mattress. The breathable mattress help the kid breathe easy and get a sound sleep at night. Foam mattresses are lightweight and you should choose the right firmness. A too firm mattress isn’t good for infants. There are several mattresses that come in duel side firmness. One side offers adequate firmness for infants and the other side is for an older kid.

Mattress with innerspring coils is expensive and heavier than others. However, it’s more firm and long-lasting. You should buy a mattress which uses no harmful or allergic components. The organic mattress is expensive and can be made of wool, cotton, plant-based foam. Usually, they are not waterproof if you want a water-resistant feature you can use a water-proof cover. You cannot actually separate these qualities, most of the mattress provides mixed features. You have to select the best one having all good qualities at the best price.

1. Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Crib Mattress Review

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Crib Mattress Review

Click Here for Price

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Crib Mattress may be the most suitable one for you in our list for the safest crib mattress 2018. In this best baby crib mattress reviews, we have come with this amazing product for infants and toddlers. Since 2002, Moonlight Slumber had been producing high-quality sleeping products. All their products are made in the USA and manufactured with high-grade materials.

This crib mattress features a dual-sided sleeping option. You can use the extra firm side for infants or the other side for toddlers, made of soft and plush foam. The foam that is used in the mattress is reliable and third-party tested. It is environment-friendly; a non-toxic material free of PVC, Lead, Phthalate, Antimony, Vinyl. This medical grade foam is water-resistant and hypoallergenic as well. The mattress cleanup is simple. You only need a damp sponge to wipe away any mess.

Moonlight Slumber uses medical grade stretch knit fabric along with SafeSewn Seams. The fabric is durable, antibacterial, water-resistant as well as odor-resistant. The SafeSewn Seams keep away the Bugs and Dust Mites. There is also a woven fire barrier. However, no chemical is used here. Many third-party organizations had tested the performance and materials of this Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Crib Mattress, ensuring the quality of the product.

We all want a safe and secure mattress for our baby. This mattress is non-indoor air polluting, does not spread any toxic scent in the air that creates a healthy environment for your baby. This lightweight product makes your work smoother while changing the sheets. We can say that this crib mattress is worth to be listed in our crib mattress buying guide for its comfort to both parents and children.


  • A lifetime guarantee against all possible manufacturer defects
  • Medical Grade Materials
  • Made in the USA with domestic components and sourced fabric
  • Third-party tested
  • Dual-sided Sleeping System
  • SafeSewn Seams
  • Water-resistant
  • Extremely safe materials
  • Easy to clean with a damp sponge


  • Too firm surface for some babies

2. Newton Baby Crib Mattress And Toddler Bed Review

Newton Baby Crib Mattress And Toddler Bed Review

Click Here for Price

We have included Newton Baby Crib Mattress And Toddler Bed in our best baby crib mattress reviews due to its impressive features. Newton Wovenaire Crib Mattress has a patented wovenaire core. About 90% internal space of this core is filled with air and covered with 3-dimensional space material. This makes the air ventilation process smoother. Newton Crib Mattress is the USA made product that’s renowned for its outstanding performance.

This crib mattress is safe for your child. It contains no harmful polyurethane foam, adhesive, glue or metal springs. The material is non-toxic as well as hypoallergenic. If your baby has the habit of rolling over in sleep, you can pick this up without any second thought. This mattress allows babies to breathe easily in this situation. Newton wovenaire crib mattress comes with a 3D spacer cover which has two layers of breathable spacer fabric. This fabric allows superior breathing process also creates soft and comfy experience for the baby.

The wovenaire core also plays a big role to create a foam-like comfortable surface for sound sleep. This product allows parents to maintain a hygienic crib. You can wash the mattress easy and clean all mold and bacteria. You can also remove the spacer cover to clean it in the washing machine. The process of cleaning the core is also simple. You can use a tub to wash it and target spots if needed.

This crib mattress is suitable for both infants and toddlers. It also is the most reasonably priced mattress of our crib mattress buying guide. It is a long lasting product, that’s why you don’t have to replace it with your growing toddler. The product is certified by Greenguard Gold that is enough to keep your peace of mind.


  • Helps to breathe when the baby sleeps on the face
  • Greenguard Gold Certified
  • Free of all harmful chemicals and materials
  • Waterproof plus durable
  • Spacer cover with Wovenaire Core


  • Need to purchase an additional soft sheet for babies those have a habit of face rubbing

3. Emily Crib Mattress by My Green Mattress Review

Emily Crib Mattress by My Green Mattress Review

Click Here for Price

Another wise addition to our best baby crib mattress reviews, Emily crib mattress by My Green Mattress is one of the best crib mattress 2018 which comes with premium features. This is an organic crib mattress which is produced from GOTS certified organic cotton. The company uses natural eco-wool to build the quilted cover. This crib mattress is Greenguard Gold certified plus it is manufactured in the USA. The materials are harmless and free from polyurethane foam.

Every mom wants her baby to sleep better at night. Emily crib mattress allows your little one a sound sleep. The mattress has a heavy duty 150 coils innerspring that offers comfort while lying on the mattress. This mattress is designed to prevent accidents and spill if your mattress protector does not work properly. You can use both sides of it. When cleaning is a hassle, simply flip it to the other side at night. The core is also well-made plus provides longevity than regular mattresses.

This product is Lead-free which is certified by UL Laboratories. If you are looking for an organic crib mattress that is handcrafted and provides long-lasting service, this may be the perfect one. The manufacturer offers a 10-year guarantee against all manufacturer defects. You can now use this with a peace of mind and pick this up from our crib mattress buying guide.


  • Certified by several third parties
  • Handcrafted with natural supplies
  • A product made in the USA
  • Free of harmful materials
  • Both sides can be used
  • 10-year guarantee against manufacturer defects
  • Years of service


  • At first, it stinks although fades after a few days

4. Babyletto Pure Core Non-Toxic Crib Mattress Review

Click Here for Price

A set of mattress core along with a cover at such a low price. Babyletto Pure Core Non-Toxic Mattress is the best crib mattress for newborns. It offers a non-toxic polyester pure core that does not smell of nasty chemicals at all. If you wish to buy a safe and secure mattress at a moderate price within our best baby crib mattress reviews, make sure to check this out.

It has a soft, dry and waterproof cover that allows you to clean it with ease. A superior material that is specialized for babies. This crib mattress is made of vegan, non-toxic materials plus no polyurethane foam or harmful chemicals are used here. The winning feature of this mattress is the double-sided core which is entirely made of recyclable materials. The core is lightweight that makes it easy to handle.

Double sides allow you to utilize the mattress for growing babies as well. It is designed to last for years and comfortable enough for both infants and toddlers. The cover is non-crinkly and gives a super soft feel to the sleeping baby. Swift removal for ease of wash and replacing. The best thing is, you will get a 10-year warranty for the Pure Core Mattress and 1-Year Warranty for the cover. This crib mattress and cover seized a place in our crib mattress buying guide due to its excellent quality plus longevity features.


  • Dual sided Mattress
  • 10 Year Warranty for Core & 1 Year for cover
  • Made of non-toxic safe materials
  • Waterproof and easily washable


  • Dimensions are not exactly the same as the manufacturer claim

5. Nook Sleep Pebble Air Ultra Lite Crib Mattress Review

Click Here for Price

The best and safest crib mattress that allows your baby to sleep comfortably at night. You are getting tons of features altogether in this Nook Sleep Pebble Air Ultra Lite Crib Mattress. This is a breathable crib mattress made of non-toxic materials. This one is unique than other mattresses of our best crib mattress reviews and crib mattress buying guide list. It features a certiPUR-US foam along with organic cotton made Eucalyptus Pebble wrap.

The certiPUR-US core contains air channels that allow smooth airflow required for the baby. The crib mattress also has a fire barrier that is free of toxic chemicals. You can choose the pebble wrap among three soft colors, made of organic pieces of cotton it creates a comfy experience. If necessary, you can buy the crib sheets for some extra charge. The latest nano-technology is used here to develop the pebble wraps, making it water-resistant. It protects the mattress cover by resisting the absorption of liquids.

You don’t need to purchase additional pads because of this pebble wrap. This crib mattress features dual-sided contrast so that you can utilize it for the growing kid in the years to come. This is a fine mattress and the USA made product. This breathable and lightweight mattress allows your baby to breathe properly during sleep on its soft surface. Keep in mind that you have to wait 24-48 hours after unboxing the package. Air expands the mattress to get to a perfect size.


  • Breathable crib mattress
  • Ultralight texture
  • CertiPUR-US nontoxic core
  • Organic pebble wraps
  • Dual-sided design
  • Water-resistant and has a non-toxic fire barrier


  • Thin mattress, depth is less than 4 inches. However, preferred by some consumers

6. Colgate Eco Classica III Dual firmness Crib mattress Review

Click Here for Price

Colgate is a well-known company since 1955, they started their journey and achieved a trustworthy place. Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness is a standard foam crib mattress that fits almost all standard cribs. It comes in orthopedic style plus has a six-inch-thick core that features dual firmness. The babies need more flat and firm area that will help develop and breathe. However, the toddlers need the softer surface that will ensure comfort.

This certiPUR certified foam is for all infants and toddlers. You can easily flip the sides as necessary to utilize the core mattress for your growing toddler. This best crib mattress is the USA made product and we included this in our list of best baby crib mattress reviews for its certified overall safety standards. It is also GreenGuard Certified that ensures indoor air quality and indicates that this crib mattress is free from nasty chemicals.

The Colgate Eco Classica III features an organic cotton cover which is waterproof. The core foam is also Eco-friendly, infused with plant oils. This mattress is lightweight, makes your task of changing sheets easier and swifter. This crib mattress is hypoallergenic, free of harmful materials, emits no chemical scent. Even with all these features, it costs less than other competing products.

On our crib mattress buying guide, you will find this impressive mattress that offers various features altogether. If you are looking for a mattress with dual side firmness, suitable for infant and toddlers along with various certified features, you can surely go for this crib mattress. With the purchase, you will get a lifetime warranty.


  • Eco foam made from plant oils
  • Organic cotton cover
  • Dual-firmness mattress core
  • Made in the USA
  • Free of harmful components
  • Lightweight and waterproof
  • Lifetime of warranty


  • Several customers reported some mattress comes with loose seams

7. Lullaby Earth Healthy Support Crib Mattress Review

Click Here for Price

Another high-performance crib mattress review among our best baby crib mattress reviews. This is a perfect selection in our list of crib mattress buying guide for its various advanced features. Lullaby Earth Healthy Support Crib Mattress is made of food-grade polyethylene plus free of harmful components and chemicals. It is waterproof which protects the mattress from getting wet from accidents with success. A complete allergy-friendly design that keeps your baby safe at night, helping them to sleep without any trouble.

This amazing crib mattress has fire barriers that meet all federal flammability requirements yet contains no flame-resistant chemicals. It is the USA made that ensures proper manufacturing. Moreover, the company offers a lifetime limited warranty for the consumers. This product passed Greenguard Gold tests for emission standards, meaning it releases no bad odor such as chemical scents. A fresh and comfy experience for your baby, nothing can be better than this.

This mattress also features two-stage firmness that optimizes for both little babies and toddlers. The extra firm side is for toddlers and the other one is for infants. It also has edge support that protects the little one from corners and edges. It has a light-weight construction that makes the chore of changing the sheets like a breeze. You may be thinking that this mattress will be a hassle to clean. However, that is not true, it allows an easy cleaning method which saves a lot of your valuable time and energy.


  • Food grade polyethylene material
  • Waterproof and seamless edge support
  • No harmful chemicals plus Allergy friendly design
  • Meets all federal flammability requirements
  • Dual-firm mattress
  • Made in the USA
  • Lifetime limited guarantee


  • Cover creates a little crinkly sound

8. Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers Crib Mattress Review

Click Here for Price

No parent wants to compromise on the quality of a product that is for their children. However, quality products cost a lot higher than you expect. That’s why we have come with this impressive crib mattress that will cost almost half than any luxurious competitor product. Our best baby crib mattress reviews list contains Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers due to its effective features at a reasonable price.

Our crib mattress buying guide shows you how to buy a good crib mattress. Regardless of its price, this crib mattress offers a good amount of features. It ensures steady support and required stability with 231-luxury-pocketed coil springs, border plus corner protections. This allows your baby to sleep in a snug surface, keeping your mind in peace. The cotton made wrap has a natural fire protection feature, that means it is entirely non-toxic with no use of chemicals. This crib mattress fulfills all flammability requirements that ensure safety together with high-performance.

The woven cover is stain resistant and it provides a protection of medical grade waterproof barrier. You can use this mattress for years. It features a 2-in-1 structure for both infants and growing toddlers. The mattress is Greenguard Gold and CertiPUR-US certified. It is not a China manufactured product rather it is made in the USA. Moreover, the manufacturer is providing a limited lifetime warranty. A perfect crib mattress that offers, required firmness, spreads no toxic scent and lasts longer.


  • Coil springs for even support
  • Border and corner protection
  • Stain-resistant cover features waterproof barrier
  • Duel side firmness
  • No toxic smells
  • Natural fire protection wrap
  • Certified by third parties
  • The USA made crib mattress
  • Limited lifetime warranty
  • Very affordable price


  • Heavier than similar crib mattresses

9. My First Memory Foam Crib Mattress Review

My First Memory Foam Crib Mattress Review

Click Here for Price

This is a high-quality crib mattress which we recommend in our best baby crib mattress reviews. The topnotch features promise a great comfort to your baby along with the required protection. My First Memory Foam Crib Mattress has a perfect size that fits almost all standard cribs. This is a superb product that is certified for its safest components. It’s one of the best crib mattress at a moderate price range available in the market achieved a place in our crib mattress buying guide.

This crib mattress comes with a flexible polyurethane foam plus a removable cover. The foam is CertiPUR-US certified that indicates it is reliable to use. The mattress cover offers a soft snug surface for your baby. The cover is waterproof, protecting the mattress from any mess. Moreover, it is easily washable. It has square corners that provide it with a snug fit, making this a suitable choice for most parents.

My First Memory Foam Crib Mattress offers fire-resistant features still fulfilling all the requirements of federal flammability and meeting all CPSC standards. Your baby will love this mattress which is made of hypoallergenic material and provides excellent comfort. No harmful chemicals used plus it protects the mattress from mite, bacteria and keeps your baby healthy and fresh.

It is apparent that you don’t want to use something that stinks of chemicals. This is an amazing crib mattress that keeps the indoor air atmosphere fresh because it has a low VOC emission ratio. It comes in a rolled-up condition within a vacuum-packed packaging. You have to wait for 24-72 hours after unpacking for it to get to its true extent.


  • Fits all standard cribs
  • CertiPUR-US certified foam
  • Soft removable cover
  • Meets federal flammability standards
  • Hypoallergenic, mite proof, antibacterial
  • Natural fire protection wrap
  • Free of nasty chemicals
  • Low VOC emission


  • It is waterproof yet sometimes gets soaked

10. Sealy Signature Brilliant Nights 2-Stage Crib Mattress Review

Sealy Signature Brilliant Nights 2-Stage Crib Mattress Review

Click Here for Price

If you are looking for a crib mattress for less than $150, this is the right one. Sealy Signature Brilliant Nights 2-Stage is a cheap crib mattress that features two-stage firmness like any other fancy brands. You can use the extra firm, cushioning surface for your toddler and the less firm, flat surface for an infant. Our crib mattress buying guide team examined this mattress and has found out the astonishing features including the long-lasting structure of this product.

This crib mattress, constructed with a 182 coil innerspring system, creates satisfactory firmness and offers durability. It has a durable steel border and 6 straight pillars. All these ensure the safety of the baby from corners and sides. This crib mattress meets several safety standards, is also certified from Greenguard Gold for no harmful chemical emission. The USA made crib mattress constructed of the US and imported parts. The manufacturer also provides a 50-year warranty on workmanship and materials. You can buy this product without giving another thought, your money won’t go to waste.

This one is an amazing crib mattress from our best baby crib mattress reviews. It has a pearl-embossed surface, is waterproof and can easily be cleaned with mild soap or damp cloth. It features a hypoallergenic cushion, strain-resistant cover, lock-stitch waterproof binding seams. The lock stitch protects the core from surface liquids as well as reduce ripping, tearing, stretching to ensure durability. Sealy Signature Brilliant Nights Crib Mattress passed various tests and certified from many third parties, ensures it’s free of nasty components and emit no chemicals.


  • Comfortable fit without overheating or chilling
  • Two-stage firmness
  • 182 coil innerspring system
  • Steel border around the sides
  • 6 straight pillars
  • Pearl-embossed waterproof cover
  • Lock-stitched binding
  • The USA made and meets various standards
  • 50-year warranty on workmanship and material


  • The cover is not removable

Final Thoughts

All these crib mattresses are reviewed based on their quality, price, components and consumer reports. Keep that in mind, every one of them has different sizes and specifications. Choose the most fitting crib mattress for your baby according to their size, thickness and other features that are most needed.